fbpx

Report Windstone Fakes/Knock offs/Infringment Pls read first

Home Forums Windstone Editions General Windstone Report Windstone Fakes/Knock offs/Infringment Pls read first

Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 1,070 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #708468
    Lokie
    Participant

      purpledragonclaw wrote:

      Ugliness is relative. My mother thought quite a few Enchantica dragons were ugly, and those are very expensive!

      I have to aggree with your mother- Enchantica dragons don’t really float my boat. I guess we all have different tastes! Don’t kill me. 😆

      #708469
      PurpleTurtle
      Participant

        The Castle [Dave wrote:

        “]

        purpleturtle wrote:

        Man that’s an fugly dragon. You see it all the time on ebay.

        I was just showing one to a nice lady who was in with her daughter. They were looking for a dragon to give to Dad for his birthday, because he loves dragons.

        I got the impression that this was a major present from the family, not just something from the daughter, but although they looked at a few of Melody’s Dragons, Mom was clearly seeing the price and not the Dragon.

        Then they saw the cheaper mass-produced dragons, hand-painted in China and made of genuine Alabasterite. There was this one with the egg and young dragon, a single dragon, a two headed dragon, and a wizard.

        They ended up buying the two-headed dragon, because it was so cool.

        I think when you have only about $25 to your name, these dragons are really not as ugly as most of us here would like to believe.

        I can definatly relate to having limited funds and I have to admit I have a number of resin and alabasterite type dragons myself. They are some really cool and well made ones out there. I never really liked that paticular sculpture, thats all I was saying 😉 .

        #708470

        Lokie wrote:

        purpledragonclaw wrote:

        Ugliness is relative. My mother thought quite a few Enchantica dragons were ugly, and those are very expensive!

        I have to aggree with your mother- Enchantica dragons don’t really float my boat. I guess we all have different tastes! Don’t kill me. 😆

        Ah, I wouldn’t kill you! I too see some Enchantica pieces as being, shall we say, visually unappealing! 😆 There are quite a few that I like, though.

        #708471
        Pegasi1978
        Participant

          http://cgi.ebay.com/Wizards-Cottage-with-Gargoyle-Figurines_W0QQitemZ130244482640QQihZ003QQcategoryZ29800QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

          Is it just me or has some one not only knocked of the look of the Wizard’s Retreat, but several of the gargoyles as well?

          #708472

          Only one of them looks like a knockoff. The retreat kind of does though. I’m not expert however.

          #708473
          BDW
          Participant

            I sent it to John on your behalf Pegasi 😀

            #708474
            PurpleTurtle
            Participant

              LOL I actually had that ‘knock-off’ gargoyle. I looks like the Roaring one, right? It’s funny because when I bought it I thought it looked really familar, then I later found out why 🙄 . I think it ended up being sold in a yard sale or something a while ago. I’m not really into gargoyles anymore anyways….

              #708475

              purpleturtle wrote:

              LOL I actually had that ‘knock-off’ gargoyle. I looks like the Roaring one, right? It’s funny because when I bought it I thought it looked really familar, then I later found out why 🙄 . I think it ended up being sold in a yard sale or something a while ago. I’m not really into gargoyles anymore anyways….

              Yeah! The roaring one! That’s what I was thinking of, I could picture the sculpt in my mind… and was drawing a blank otherwise. 🙄

              #708476

              I just found a couple! They both look like Mother Dragon knockoffs. Here’s the first one:

              http://cgi.ebay.com/Dragon-Lullabye-Garden-Sculpture-NEW-IN-BOX_W0QQitemZ250279703402QQihZ015QQcategoryZ86929QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

              And the second one. This one is a known knockoff in a different finish.

              http://cgi.ebay.com/LARGE-MYTHICAL-DRAGON-STATUE-EARTH-COOL-FINISH_W0QQitemZ320283432760QQihZ011QQcategoryZ86929QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

              Does anyone else think the first one is a knockoff? It has a fairy in it, but still. 😕

              #708477
              Laurie
              Participant

                The second sure is. I hope the first isn’t, I really want that for my garden. I’ve been looking forever. Quick let me know!!!

                #708478
                BDW
                Participant

                  I don’t think the first one would be concidered a knock-off, it’s just a dragon curled around a fairy The scales and wings don’t look anything like the mother dragon. But the second one John has gotten it before.

                  #708479
                  Jennifer
                  Keymaster

                    The first one? Probably not. Nothing about it reads as “Windstone” to me.

                    The second one probably is, and is one that John knows about. 🙂

                    Volunteer mod- I'm here to help! Email me for the best response: nambroth at gmail.com
                    My art: featherdust.com

                    #708480

                    I agree with everyone… a dragon lying down would be hard to copyright, there has to be more then the basic pose to be copyright, I think. Like similar style of head, scales, color, etc. Or the EXACT same pose, and this one isn’t exactly the same.

                    #708481
                    darjeb
                    Participant
                      #708482

                      darjeb wrote:

                      I don’t recall seeing this one

                      http://cgi.ebay.com/Ceramic-Mold-Duncans-Baby-Imaginary-Dragon_W0QQitemZ200248234252QQihZ010QQcategoryZ83898QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

                      I have this mold…I’d have to look at his date, but he may be older than Melody’s work…not sure though.

                      I have one here…setting it next to Melody’s…it is a lot bigger almost as big as the Royal hatchers, also Mel’s baby has both front paws out, tail and a wing, this guy has only one leg out and his tail, the wings only stick up but neither are out, he has no rock base and his egg is broken in a totally different manner.

                      Comparing the two, I don’t consider this piece a knockoff. I will also look at my mold and find out the copyright date on it…if I am right, it may be older than Mel’s little dragon.

                      Kyrin

                    Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 1,070 total)
                    • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.