He is Beautiful, I had a female shepard called Cheyanne, also a male called Kodie.
When I was training them I would give them a treat, one of those small generic milk bones,
they loved them. Every time I took them out and brought them in they went to where
I kept the treats and sat there until I gave them one. They new they would get a treat
everytime they went, it’s an idea to try. Also I never fed them after 5:00 pm, in the
morning I’d feed them and take them out 1/2 hour later and the same thing around
dinner time, then before I went to bed, Hope it helps.